A cold Coke on a hot day might be your idea of simple pleasure, but no one is mistaking it for a natural product. Bloomberg Businessweek's Deena Shanker, who writes the Extra Salt column, drops by to talk about politicians' surprising embrace of cane sugar sodas. Plus: The Elon, Inc., podcast on his companies and his children, and Japan's struggles with tourism crowds. If this email was forwarded to you, click here to sign up. Too much added sugar is bad for us. That's true when it's in a cookie or a bottle of soda. It's true when it's in the form of high fructose corn syrup or cane sugar. We've known this for quite some time now. So seeing the US secretary of health and human services celebrate a bottle of soda because it's made with the latter instead of the former, I'm forced to echo the famous question of Jacobim Mugatu: "Doesn't anyone notice this? I feel like I'm taking crazy pills!" Backing up just briefly: President Donald Trump in a Truth Social post last week said that Coca-Cola Co. had agreed to use cane sugar—presumably instead of high fructose corn syrup—in beverages for the US market. The company then demurred, saying that more details would follow. A few days later, HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. commented on an announcement on X from restaurant chain Steak 'n Shake that it would offer Cokes made with "real cane sugar." "MAHA is winning," he wrote. In its quarterly earnings report on Tuesday, the Coca-Cola made the news official. In the fall it will launch a product for American consumers, alongside the ones it already sells, made with US cane sugar. You'd have to be on crazy pills to think this is a win for American health. Make room on the shelf for more Coke. Photographer: David Paul Morris/Bloomberg There are few products quite as unhealthy as a bottle of soda. (Don't get me wrong—as a little treat, soda is fine. So are cookies and candy. Everything in moderation.) As a consistent part of a person's diet, regular soda is very, very bad. First and foremost, there's the sugar: A 12-ounce bottle of Coca-Cola has 39 grams of added sugar, which is more than the American Heart Association says an adult should consume in an entire day. There's also the form it takes: It's easy to drink too much sugar, because we're less likely to feel full from a beverage. Soda has no other nutrients in it; it's basically drinkable, caffeinated candy. Plus, it's a major cause of tooth decay. As the Mississippi State Department of Health puts it, "carbonation, sugar and acids in soft drinks weaken tooth enamel and encourage the growth of bacteria." And then there's the artificial food dye. Such colorings have taken center stage in Kennedy's Make America Healthy Again movement, in large part thanks to Vani Hari, the longtime online activist better known as Food Babe. Company after company has committed to removing Blue Nos. 1 and 2, Green No. 3, Red No. 40, and Yellow Nos. 5 and 6 from their products. The announcements come after years of critics highlighting that the dyes may be carcinogenic, may lead to hyperactivity in some kids, and exist solely to market junk food, usually to children. A bottle of Coke doesn't use those dyes—but it uses another one called caramel coloring. Hari earlier waged an entire, yearlong campaign against it, eventually getting Starbucks to get rid of it. "I think it's one of the most hazardous chemicals being added to our food," she wrote back in 2014. ("Caramel coloring, when produced with ammonia, contains the contaminants 2-methylimidazole and 4-methylimidazole," according to the Center for Science in the Public Interest, which then lists multiple health authorities linking them to cancer.) None of these problems are solved by swapping in cane sugar for high fructose corn syrup, though Hari told me the benefit is really that by avoiding genetically modified corn, less of the herbicide glyphosate is used. Coca-Cola declined to comment on its changes. "Let's be clear: No one is calling soda a health food. The secretary made a simple point—Americans deserve real ingredients, not ultraprocessed additives," says Andrew Nixon, an HHS spokesperson. "We welcome any move that signals a return to natural ingredients." If anybody is winning, it's Coca-Cola, which reported second-quarter sales growth and profit yesterday that beat Wall Street's expectations. As of Tuesday's close, Coke has seen its share price for the year jump 11.89%, solidly ahead of the S&P 500's 7.28% advance. Consumers are still buying the company's drinks. With its newest offering enjoying not just Kennedy's support but also the endorsement of Trump, one of Diet Coke's most famous fans, more soda sales look likely. Related: The push for more cane-sweetened Coke products means the US may need to import more expensive sweetener from Mexico and Brazil—particularly if other companies follow suit. |
No comments